DC Universe     [all categories]
  DC Universe Archives
  Ashcan Editions

Post New Topic  Post A Reply
profile | register | preferences | faq

UBBFriend: Email This Page to Someone! next newest topic | next oldest topic
Author Topic:   Ashcan Editions
paladin
Member
posted February 26, 2003 02:47 AM     Click Here to See the Profile for paladin        Reply w/Quote
Back in 30's/40's did DC publish any Ashcans of their comics?

Thanks for any info!!


IP: Logged

CMCINTYRE3600
Member
posted February 26, 2003 09:41 AM     Click Here to See the Profile for CMCINTYRE3600   Click Here to Email CMCINTYRE3600        Reply w/Quote
quote:
Originally posted by paladin:
Back in 30's/40's did DC publish any Ashcans of their comics?

Thanks for any info!!


What exactly is an Ashcan editon? I've heard that used several times, but I still don't get it.
Chris

IP: Logged

vze2
Member
posted February 26, 2003 05:32 PM     Click Here to See the Profile for vze2        Reply w/Quote
An ashcan is a photocopied comic used to secure a copyright. If I recall, you can see one in Shazam! Archives volume 1.

IP: Logged

Old Dude
Member
posted February 26, 2003 07:05 PM     Click Here to See the Profile for Old Dude   Click Here to Email Old Dude        Reply w/Quote
I think I recall seeing one for the '40s Flash comic.

Personally, I find ashcans too limited to be interesting.

IP: Logged

Bgztl
Member
posted February 26, 2003 10:20 PM     Click Here to See the Profile for Bgztl   Click Here to Email Bgztl        Reply w/Quote
quote:
Originally posted by Old Dude:

Personally, I find ashcans too limited to be interesting.

I've always preferred spitoons, myself.

------------------
Bgztl a/k/a Jack Holt

All of human wisdom is summed up in two words: wait and hope.

--Alexandre Dumas

IP: Logged

CMCINTYRE3600
Member
posted February 27, 2003 09:19 AM     Click Here to See the Profile for CMCINTYRE3600   Click Here to Email CMCINTYRE3600        Reply w/Quote
quote:
Originally posted by vze2:
An ashcan is a photocopied comic used to secure a copyright. If I recall, you can see one in Shazam! Archives volume 1.

Hmm. Well, I haven't started the Shazam Archive series yet, so I missed out on that. But I think it's great that DC would put something like that in their Archive for historical and completeness purposes.
Chris

IP: Logged

OldGuy
Member
posted February 27, 2003 02:30 PM     Click Here to See the Profile for OldGuy        Reply w/Quote
quote:
Originally posted by vze2:
An ashcan is a photocopied comic used to secure a copyright. If I recall, you can see one in Shazam! Archives volume 1.

Well technically an ashcan is used to secure a trademark on the title and not a copyright on the material. In fact most ashcan comics use previously copyrighted material wih just a new cover logo. Usually some old cover (or spalsh) art had a new logo pasted above it and the page was printed in black and white and stapled with the interior of some old comic. This was then registered to secure the trademark. An ashcan of Whiz Comics was produced as Flash Comics, but DC just beat Fawcett with their own ashcan for that title. This shows the importance of ashcans. If Fawcett had just gone ahead and produced a complete run of the first issue of Flash Comics, they'd have had to destroy them since DC had secured the trademark.

DC produced many ashcans over the years (some like Superwoman merely to prevent others from using the title). The DC ashcans I'm aware of are:

Federal Men 1936
Action Comics 1937
Action Funnies 1938
Double Action Funnies 1938
Radio Funnies 1939
Flash Comics 1939
All Star Comics 1940
Old Glory Comics 1941
Red White & Blue Comics 1941
World's Best Comics 1941
Superwoman 1942
Leading Comics 1942
Headline Comics 1942
Boy Commandos Comics 1942
Screen Gems 1945
Real Fact Comics 1946
Animal Antics 1946
The Phantom Stranger 1952
Wonderful World of Comics 1956
Rock 'n' Roll Comics 1956

Oh and those days of course they were not photocopied, of course.

IP: Logged

James Friel
Member
posted February 27, 2003 02:36 PM     Click Here to See the Profile for James Friel   Click Here to Email James Friel        Reply w/Quote
Damn!
Imagine if there really had been a DC title called Rock'n'Roll Comics!

On second thought, considering the lame results of every attempt on the DC staff's part to be hip in the '60s...

IP: Logged

NecessaryImpurity
Member
posted February 27, 2003 03:02 PM     Click Here to See the Profile for NecessaryImpurity        Reply w/Quote
DC did produce a rock and roll comic: Pat Boone. Five issues in '59 and '60.

You'll have to excuse me while I go drink heavily, to remove the idea "Pat Boone is a rock and roller" from my mind. This may require psychotherapy, in addition to alchohol.

IP: Logged

James Friel
Member
posted February 27, 2003 03:07 PM     Click Here to See the Profile for James Friel   Click Here to Email James Friel        Reply w/Quote
quote:
Originally posted by NecessaryImpurity:
DC did produce a rock and roll comic: Pat Boone. Five issues in '59 and '60.

You'll have to excuse me while I go drink heavily, to remove the idea "Pat Boone is a rock and roller" from my mind. This may require psychotherapy, in addition to alchohol.


One of the more hideous memories of my TV watching youth is having seen Pat Boone perform Tootie Frutti on the Arthur Godfrey Show. Horrible. Horrible.

"Got a gal. Name is Sue. She knows just what to do..."
Even at whatever tender age I was at the time (10?), the thought that Pat himself probably didn't know what to do was inescapable...

IP: Logged

CMCINTYRE3600
Member
posted February 27, 2003 03:18 PM     Click Here to See the Profile for CMCINTYRE3600   Click Here to Email CMCINTYRE3600        Reply w/Quote
quote:
Originally posted by James Friel:
One of the more hideous memories of my TV watching youth is having seen Pat Boone perform Tootie Frutti on the Arthur Godfrey Show. Horrible. Horrible.

"Got a gal. Name is Sue. She knows just what to do..."
Even at whatever tender age I was at the time (10?), the thought that Pat himself probably didn't know what to do was inescapable...


One of my more horrible memories was of Pat Boone, dressed all in leather, doing some Ozzy song on Leno a few years ago....

Actually, it's not much of a memory since I seemed to have blocked the actuall performace from my mind. But I do remember him on Leno's couch with full on biker gear.... *shudder*

IP: Logged

James Friel
Member
posted February 27, 2003 04:12 PM     Click Here to See the Profile for James Friel   Click Here to Email James Friel        Reply w/Quote
It's always struck me as odd that no one ever licensed the right to do an Adventures of Elvis Presley comic.
Hell, it could still be a smash...

IP: Logged

chris_ccl
New Member
posted February 27, 2003 04:19 PM     Click Here to See the Profile for chris_ccl        Reply w/Quote
Here is a pic of a graded Ashcan Edition of Superman #1 that was auctioned off some time ago. I don't know what it sold for.
http://www.collectedcomicslibrary.com/archives/superman_action_comics/images/supes1_ashcan.jpg

Chris

------------------
Collected Comics Library

IP: Logged

Old Dude
Member
posted February 27, 2003 05:01 PM     Click Here to See the Profile for Old Dude   Click Here to Email Old Dude        Reply w/Quote
In more recent times, Mike W. Barr and an artist worked up an ashcan for The Maze Agency to secure the trademark. From that, I assume there are other ashcans done for creator-owned titles.

IP: Logged

Wildcat
New Member
posted February 27, 2003 05:12 PM     Click Here to See the Profile for Wildcat        Reply w/Quote
AC Comics still produce ashcan comics, mainly Retro Comics which showcase golden age chars like CatMan and Kitten, Rocketman and Jet Girl, etc...

IP: Logged

Michael Bise
Member
posted February 27, 2003 07:01 PM     Click Here to See the Profile for Michael Bise   Click Here to Email Michael Bise        Reply w/Quote
Was there an actual Supewoman in [iii]Superwoman[/i] #1?

Isn't the Captain Thunder ash-can in the SHAZAM! Archives??

------------------
Rock a little,

Michael
"I will ride through the snow in an old-fashioned carriage
Drawn by a small golden horse... she runs like the wind..."
"Julia" ~ Stevie Nicks

IP: Logged

Old Dude
Member
posted February 28, 2003 12:09 AM     Click Here to See the Profile for Old Dude   Click Here to Email Old Dude        Reply w/Quote
quote:
Originally posted by James Friel:
One of the more hideous memories of my TV watching youth is having seen Pat Boone perform Tootie Frutti on the Arthur Godfrey Show.

Do you also remember how HUGE a following he had then? I have two older sisters who were teenagers during the Boone Boom. Remember Lois Lane's room in the story where Pat appeared? It was wall-to-wall Pat Boone merchandise. Well, that was how my sisters' room looked.

IP: Logged

James Friel
Member
posted February 28, 2003 12:51 AM     Click Here to See the Profile for James Friel   Click Here to Email James Friel        Reply w/Quote
quote:
Originally posted by Old Dude:
Do you also remember how HUGE a following he had then? I have two older sisters who were teenagers during the Boone Boom. Remember Lois Lane's room in the story where Pat appeared? It was wall-to-wall Pat Boone merchandise. Well, that was how my sisters' room looked.

He was the Anti-Elvis.
Millions of white middle-class suburban parents who were horrified by the idea of their precious virginal children being corrupted by the likes of Elvis, Little Richard, Dion & the Belmonts, Chuck Berry, or Jerry Lee Lewis viewed him as the Great White(bread) Hope.
His popularity was intense while it lasted, but it was artificially generated, a lot like that of the Monkees a decade later (except that the Monkees had the redeeming qualities of humor and perhaps talent that was somewhat less limited than Pat's.) The Monkees, against many people's expectations, though, turned out actually to be entertaining.
Given his blandness, even in the age of Lawrence Welk, it's not surprising that his popularity fairly quickly migrated toward the upper end of the age spectrum. What right-thinking teenage girl could possibly remain infatuated for long with a guy who was so damned duriful and wholesome and respectful of authority?

IP: Logged

OldGuy
Member
posted February 28, 2003 01:33 AM     Click Here to See the Profile for OldGuy        Reply w/Quote
quote:
Originally posted by Michael Bise:
Was there an actual Supewoman in [iii]Superwoman[/i] #1?

Isn't the Captain Thunder ash-can in the SHAZAM! Archives??


No there was almost no new material in any of the ashcans. I have a list someplace, but the only new material I recall was a Creig Flessel cover on Action Comics and a Leo Omealia cover on Action Funies. The later was later used as the cover to Action #3, I think. The Superwoman cover depicted Dr. Fate in his full helmet. Maybe DC decided the completely masked flying man might possibly be taken for a woman. (Or they may simply not have cared.)

At least the cover of the Flash Comics / Captain Tuhnder was in the Archives and *I think* the complete story along with a second
ashcan cover for Thrill Comics. That was also pulled when Nedor published Thrilling. Fawcett settled on Whiz.

IP: Logged

Wayne1776
Member
posted March 01, 2003 06:24 PM     Click Here to See the Profile for Wayne1776   Click Here to Email Wayne1776        Reply w/Quote
Comic Book Marketplace No. 71, Sept. 1999 cover features DC's Ashcans. The article lists 48 known Ashcans and in some instances the - at the time the article was written - the owners of them.
It lists the source of the covers and the interiors that the Ashcans were composed of.
The ones they list are:
ACTION COMICS # 1, ACTION FUNNIES (NN), ALL-AMERICAN COMICS (NN),ALL-AMERICAN MEN OF WAR (NN), ALL STAR COMICS #1, ANIMAL ANTICS (NN),
BOY COMMANDOS COMICS #1, BOY COMMANDOS COMICS (NN), COMMANDOS #1, DOUBLE ACTION COMICS #2, FEDERAL MEN COMICS (NN?), FLASH COMICS #1, FUNNY FOLKS(NN?), GIRL'S LOVE STORIES (NN), HEADLINE COMICS (NN), HERE'S HOWIE (NN), HOUSE OF MYSTERY (NN), LEADING COMICS (NN), MOVIES CARTOONS (NN), MOVIE FABLES (NN), MOVIE GEMS (NN), THE MYSTERIOUS STRANGER (NN), MYSTERY TRAIL (NN), OLD GLORY COMICS (NN), ONCE UPON A TIME (NN???), OUR MEN AT WAR (NN), THE PHANTOM STRANGER (NN), RADIO FUNNIES #1, REAL FACT COMICS (NN), REAL SCREEN FUNNIES #1, RED, WHITE & BLUE COMICS (NN), ROCK 'N' ROLL COMICS (NN???), SCREEN CARTOONS (NN), SCREEN COMICS (NN), SCREEN FABLES (NN), SCREEN FUNNIES (NN), SCREEN GEMS (NN), STAR SPANGLED WAR STORIES (NN), STRANGE ADVENTURES (NN), SUPERBOY (NN), SUPERGIRL (NN), SUPERMAN COMICS (NN), SUPERMAN. . . SUPERHOMBRE (NN), SUPERWOMAN (NN), WESTERN SERENADE COMICS (NN), WONDERFUL WORLD FOR BOYS AND GIRLS (NN???),
WONDER WOMAN #1, WORLD'S BEST COMICS (NN).

The article is by Gary Colabuono who owns many of these Ashcans. Most came from Sol Harrison (who went from his career at DC from 16 year old color separationist to eventual President of DC)!

The paper that these are printed on is velox paper. Multiple copies of ashcans were produced by photographing the mock-ups of the logos and covers and interiors. When printed it produces an extremly clear and sharp black and white image. Because of this 50-60 year old practice the ashcans are virtually impossible to counterfeit. (Info from the article in CBM -- from the article I am still unclear as to if the interiors were also printed on velox paper).

To spotlight one comic, Colobuono says of DOUBLE ACTION COMICS, Jan. 1940 - "Double Action Comics #2 is one of the rarest, least understood, and most controversial DC comics in existence! Although most experts contend that it is clearly an ashcan (because a copy was found in the Sol Harrison collection of ashcans)... others mantain that the origin of this DC enigma is still in question. This is because, unlike other DC ashcans, Double Action # 2 has a printed cover price and a printed color cover (both from the bottom 3/4 of Adventure (Comics) #37 art), is a #2 issue (instead of a #1 or a NN), and contains stories from more than a single comic book. (Among other b&w contents, it contains two 4-page Dr. Occult stories by Siegel and Shuster - "Vampires Venom," and "The Spectral Killer" - likely from two different issues of More Fun. This disproves the theory that the interior is a coverless copy of a previously published issue of Adventure, Detective or More Fun.)" This is side-bar information that accompanies a full-page color picture of Double Action Comics #2.

IP: Logged

All times are ET (US)

next newest topic | next oldest topic

Administrative Options: Close Topic | Archive/Move | Delete Topic
Post New Topic  Post A Reply
Hop to:

Contact Us | DC Comics

Copyright © 2003 DC Comics
DC COMICS PRIVACY INFORMATION

Powered by Infopop www.infopop.com © 2000
Ultimate Bulletin Board 5.47